look out, it's Wednesday
Nov. 13th, 2024 01:37 pmAnd I'm still here. Which is something, overall. In any case, I have been doing some reading over the last week or so.
On paper, Persians: The Age of the Great Kings by Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones. As far as I can tell this book was written in 2022, which amazes me because it is so obdurately old fashioned a work of history, even of political history. The discussion of the royal women (because this is not the kind of book which cares about women who are not the wives, mothers, or concubines of the Persian kings) is incredibly naive. But if what you would like is a rollicking narrative of the Persian kings from Cyrus to Darius III this is the book for you. When I lie awake at night and my thoughts start running away with me I sit up and read five or ten pages of it.
Like a lot of popular histories the book has no proper citations within the text, and since I am not a specialist on Persia I have no way of knowing how well-grounded these lurid stories of court intrigue are but I am not strongly inclined to take them at face value. I guess Ctesias is the source for a lot of it but I feel like the author underestimates his prejudices about women and barbarians just because he isn't as bad as Herodotus.
On the internet, The Winter of Widows (524008 words) by laughingnell, an ASOIAF self-insert (or maybe more properly isekai? I'm not always clear on the difference) about a modern person born as the second daughter of a very minor Riverlands house; the story is set in the immediate aftermath of the Dance of the Dragons. It's really lovely: it's an uplift story but the uplift is about being humane and caring about other people. There is a little agricultural and technological development (four fields, glassworks and a spinning jenny) but none of the focus on military technology and political power that often overwhelm SI stories. Magic is real in this universe, as one would expect of something that takes the SI premise seriously, but not a panacea. The main character and her inner circle are all wonderfully-written, good people, even if they have some flaws. This is a very hopeful work, and I needed that this week.
It's a WIP, currently on chapter 62 of ???. Even if there's never another chapter written, I would recommend it.
On paper, Persians: The Age of the Great Kings by Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones. As far as I can tell this book was written in 2022, which amazes me because it is so obdurately old fashioned a work of history, even of political history. The discussion of the royal women (because this is not the kind of book which cares about women who are not the wives, mothers, or concubines of the Persian kings) is incredibly naive. But if what you would like is a rollicking narrative of the Persian kings from Cyrus to Darius III this is the book for you. When I lie awake at night and my thoughts start running away with me I sit up and read five or ten pages of it.
Like a lot of popular histories the book has no proper citations within the text, and since I am not a specialist on Persia I have no way of knowing how well-grounded these lurid stories of court intrigue are but I am not strongly inclined to take them at face value. I guess Ctesias is the source for a lot of it but I feel like the author underestimates his prejudices about women and barbarians just because he isn't as bad as Herodotus.
On the internet, The Winter of Widows (524008 words) by laughingnell, an ASOIAF self-insert (or maybe more properly isekai? I'm not always clear on the difference) about a modern person born as the second daughter of a very minor Riverlands house; the story is set in the immediate aftermath of the Dance of the Dragons. It's really lovely: it's an uplift story but the uplift is about being humane and caring about other people. There is a little agricultural and technological development (four fields, glassworks and a spinning jenny) but none of the focus on military technology and political power that often overwhelm SI stories. Magic is real in this universe, as one would expect of something that takes the SI premise seriously, but not a panacea. The main character and her inner circle are all wonderfully-written, good people, even if they have some flaws. This is a very hopeful work, and I needed that this week.
It's a WIP, currently on chapter 62 of ???. Even if there's never another chapter written, I would recommend it.