Aug. 6th, 2005
(no subject)
Aug. 6th, 2005 02:59 pmMinisinoo's poll on current and old canon in fanfic writing (look, go read the poll, it will make sense) got me thinking about different ways of ignoring canon. I thought I'd write about them here rather than wibble on about the X-Files in her journal.
( denial fic and fix-it fic )
( closed canon and my crazy problems )
The point, I think, is that there's a difference between stories in which the author denies that acanonical event took place, and stories in which an author decides to try to fix a canonical event (usually something she doesn't like); in addition, an author can simply choose to set a story earlier than the current timeline. Each of these is doing something rather different with regard to canon, I think. And I have a distinct weakness for fix-it stories.
( denial fic and fix-it fic )
( closed canon and my crazy problems )
The point, I think, is that there's a difference between stories in which the author denies that acanonical event took place, and stories in which an author decides to try to fix a canonical event (usually something she doesn't like); in addition, an author can simply choose to set a story earlier than the current timeline. Each of these is doing something rather different with regard to canon, I think. And I have a distinct weakness for fix-it stories.